The “S status” for Ukrainians in Europe, particularly in Switzerland, represents a temporary protection mechanism designed to address the humanitarian needs of those fleeing themilitary conflict in Ukraine. This status was introduced in March 2022 and has been a crucial tool in managing the influx of refugees without overburdening the traditional asylum systems.
S Status in Switzerland
Switzerland’s S status offers rapid and uncomplicated protection to Ukrainian refugees. It allows them to bypass the lengthy asylum process, granting immediate access to housing, financial support, medical care and work market. This status is valid until March 2025, with potential for extension depending on the situation in Ukraine[1][2][4]. It was recently extented until the March 2026
The Swiss government has recently announced an extension of the S protection status for Ukrainians until March 2026. This decision reflects the ongoing instability in Ukraine and aims to provide clarity and support to the approximately 66,000 individuals who have been granted this status in Switzerland.
Overview of S Status Extension
The extension of S status is significant as it allows beneficiaries to continue receiving essential support measures, including access to housing, healthcare, and the labor market. The Swiss government emphasized that the extension is necessary due to the lack of a stable situation in Ukraine, which prevents many from returning safely home. This move not only aids the ukrainian refugees but also helps cantons, municipalities, and employers plan for the future.[5]
Benefits of S Status
Under the S status, Ukrainians in Switzerland enjoy several rights:
-Residence and Work: Beneficiaries can reside in Switzerland and engage in gainful employment, including self-employment, without needing prior authorization. They can even set up a companies including the legal form AG and GmbH.
– Access to Services: They have access to social welfare, healthcare, and education for children, which is crucial for their integration into Swiss society.
– Travel: Those with S status can travel abroad and return to Switzerland without needing a separate travel permit. They are also able to travel back to Ukraine but no longer than 10 days with prior notification of the governmental bodies.
Application and Renewal Process
The S status is initially valid for one year but can be extended. Beneficiaries must apply for an extension no earlier than three months and no later than 14 days before their current permit expires. The application process involves submitting necessary documents to the local authorities (Gemeinde), including a completed application form and a photocopy of the passport.
Integration Support
Recognizing the challenges faced by refugees, the Swiss government has also extended support measures focused on integration, particularly in the workplace. This includes language acquisition programs and access to vocational training, which are essential for helping refugees adapt and thrive in their new environment.
While S status has been instrumental in providing immediate relief, it also presents challenges. In Switzerland, the status allows access to the labor market and education, but integration remains a concern. The Swiss Refugee Council has called for more integration measures to help refugees assimilate into society[2].
The extension of S status for Ukrainians in Switzerland until March 2026 is a crucial step in providing ongoing support to those affected by the conflict. It not only ensures their safety and well-being but also facilitates their integration into Swiss society, allowing them to rebuild their lives amidst the uncertainty of their homeland’s future.[9][10]
S Status Across Europe
The European Union has implemented a similar Temporary Protection Directive in Europe, which most member states have adopted. This directive provides expedited stay, residence, and work rights for Ukrainians and eligible residents fleeing Ukraine.
Impact and Challenges
The S status is a vital component of Europe’s response to the Ukrainian refugee crisis. It provides necessary protection and support while maintaining the functionality of the asylum system. However, continuous evaluation and adaptation of the criteria and integration measures are essential to ensure that the needs of refugees are adequately met. As the situation in Ukraine evolves, so too must the policies surrounding S status to ensure they remain effective and fair.
Key Differences Between S Status and Traditional Asylum Procedures
The S status in Switzerland differs from traditional asylum procedures in several key ways:
Eligibility Criteria
– S status is specifically designed for Ukrainian nationals who were residing in Ukraine before February 24, 2022 and have since entered Switzerland. Family members can also apply.
– Traditional asylum is open to individuals of any nationality who are unable or unwilling to return to their country of origin due to a well-founded fear of persecution[11], political, military, economical or social reasons.
Application Process
-S status applicants undergo a simplified procedure, usually within 1 day. First they need to register for the application of the S Status within the website of the State Secretariat for Migration (SEM) [12]. Sometimes there might be a brief interview to clarify somequestions[13] if the person lived before in other countries or stayed too long and did not arrive directly from Ukraine. If the short interview did not provide enough clarification during the short interview with SEM, they might get a brief where they should answer the questions more detailed and send the necessary documents or they also might be invited to a longer interview in a couple of months with lawyer and SEM where everything will be documented in the protocol.
-Asylum seekers must go through a more comprehensive process, including detailed interviews and submission of evidence to prove their refugee status[12]. They might await for interviews a few months. The interview itself might take a few days and then decision itself can take a few months. The asylum seeker als received free legala aid from the gvernment, meaning they will receive a lawyer which will accompany them during the interview with SEM.
Rights and Benefits
– S status holders receive a 1-year residence permit that can be extended. They have immediate access to employment, social assistance, healthcare, and education[13].
– Asylum seekers have more limited rights during the application process. They may face restrictions on employment and have to wait for a decision on their claim before accessing certain benefits[11].
Duration of Stay
– S status is intended as a temporary measure and can be terminated based on the situation in Ukraine. After 5 years, holders may be granted a regular residence permit if still in need of protection[13].
– Recognized refugees under the asylum system are granted permanent residence in Switzerland. Their status can only be revoked in exceptional circumstances[11] meaning the change of the situation in their home countries which is quite similar to the S Status termination.
In summary, S status provides a faster, more flexible route to protection for Ukrainians, while traditional asylum procedures follow a more comprehensive, case-by-case approach for individuals of any nationality. Both systems aim to provide refuge to those fleeing persecution or conflict. However, at the current process people fleeing from the war in Ukraine are not eligible for the Asylum process.
Citations:
[1] Switzerland changes the rules for granting temporary protection https://visitukraine.today/de/blog/4121/switzerland-changes-the-rules-for-granting-temporary-protection-not-everyone-will-be-able-to-obtain-s-status-and-some-will-even-lose-it
[2] Status S – Schweizerische Flüchtlingshilfe https://www.fluechtlingshilfe.ch/themen/asyl-in-der-schweiz/aufenthaltsstatus/status-s
[3] Worldwide/Ukraine: Temporary Protection Status – Country-Specific … https://www.fragomen.com/insights/european-unionukraine-temporary-protection-status-country-specific-updates.html
[4] Fragen und Antworten für Geflüchtete aus der Ukraine – SEM https://www.sem.admin.ch/sem/de/home/sem/aktuell/ukraine-krieg.html
[5] https://www.sem.admin.ch/sem/en/home/sem/aktuell/ukraine-krieg.html
[6] https://www.fluechtlingshilfe.ch/themen/asyl-in-der-schweiz/aufenthaltsstatus/status-s
[7] https://www.sem.admin.ch/sem/de/home/sem/aktuell/ukraine-krieg.html
[8] https://www.sem.admin.ch/sem/en/home/sem/medien/mm.msg-id-98405.html
[9] [PDF] Information on ‘protection status S’ in Switzerland https://euaa.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2022-06/Booklet_Switzerland_EN.pdf
[10] Situation Ukraine Refugee Situation – UNHCR Data Portal
[12] https://www.sem.admin.ch/sem/en/home/asyl/ukraine/registerme.html
[13] Worldwide/Ukraine: Temporary Protection Status – Country-Specific … https://www.fragomen.com/insights/european-unionukraine-temporary-protection-status-country-specific-updates.html
